Most people are either hot or cold on Roethlisberger's legacy so far. Many people continue to doubt his place as an elite quarterback. While Ben has amassed one of the highest winning percentages among active QB's in the NFL, his inconsistent play and the fact he benefits from playing on a team with an above-average running game and dominating defense leads to this line of thinking. Many supporters have come out for Ben over the course of this year's playoffs, citing his knack for keeping plays alive and his inate ability to lead his team back to victory.
As for myself, as most probably know, I'm still kind of hesitant to anoint Ben as a top-3 QB. I respect Ben's track record. He has done more in terms of winning faster than most other QB's in NFL history. He put together an All-Pro season last year, throwing for over 3000 yards and 32 td's. He has shown flashes of having the ability to become elite. But in my opinion, he hasn't consistenly done enough to warrant being mentioned in the same sentence as Tom Brady and Peyton Manning. I am a realist when it comes to sports, I've been a Steelers fan since birth, but I refuse to fall into the trap of other Yinzer Steeler fans who blindly deify their favorite Steelers and refuse to recognize other star players on their hated rivals. If we were ranking the greatest game managing QB's in the NFL, Ben would be #1 in my book. But when it comes down to being an elite QB, Ben just isn't on that level just yet. He is only 26, and his prime should be just ahead, so I'm not one to say that he will never be at that level. But to say he is right now is ludicrous.
While I'm on my pedestal, to quote the great Peter Griffin, another thing that really grinds my gears is the fact that most Steeler fans are willing to grant Ben a reprieve when he struggles, but in most cases the same courtesy is not extended to Willie Parker. I'm amazed at how many look down upon Parker and refuse to acknowledge his contributions to the Steelers over the past four years.